All Decade Team voting, link in 1st comment

33jacket said:
ditto.

my reasoning. If there was one qb u wanted when it mattered. Josh. Plus he did what he did in 2008 in a totally new scheme. And acc title

but darn it was close cuz jt 2 cofh wins and
Orange bowl
Click to expand...
Josh would kill you if he knew you voted against him.
 
GTsapper said:
Came here to brag that I took Nesbitt over Justin Thomas on the 1st Team QB
Click to expand...
Does it not matter that Josh’s best years weren’t in the decade in question? If it’s a comparison of Josh’s 2010 versus JT’s career, then it’s really no contest.
 
JoeCakeEater said:
Does it not matter that Josh’s best years weren’t in the decade in question? If it’s a comparison of Josh’s 2010 versus JT’s career, then it’s really no contest.
Click to expand...
I voted for JT for this reason. If we're comparing entire careers, then it's an interesting argument. I think I'd still vote for JT, because Nesbitt had some really damn good players around him in 2009. Both were fantastic players, though.
 
JoeCakeEater said:
Does it not matter that Josh’s best years weren’t in the decade in question? If it’s a comparison of Josh’s 2010 versus JT’s career, then it’s really no contest.
Click to expand...

true. I viewed as a career for each player in the decade not just the years that they played in the time period.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top