The difference between The #1 NFL team and the #32 team is QB play and maybe 2-3 playmakers. It's why the top seeds in the playoffs hardly ever win the Super Bowl.
My point is that it doesn't matter what NFL team you pick, they would destroy any college team (Bama included).
I agree with your result, but not the reasoning (at least fully).
Bama has a bunch of playmakers on its current team. Probably on par with the number of playmakers the Jags have.
The difference to me is not the number of studs, but instead the average level of talent. For example, maybe half of Bama's starting lineup this year eventually has a career in the NFL.
ALL of the Jaguars starting lineup has that, not even counting its bench players - many of whom are 5-7 year NFL vets. I mean, Jacksonville's second string consists of guys who are better across the board than Bama's starting lineup. The very end of their bench still consists of guys who would start at just about any position for Bama.
The way of looking at it isn't hey, Bama's best players are going to be picked in the first round and start. The way to look at it is that Bama's next line of players, the guys who aren't starting, are probably not going to the NFL. The back end of Bama's starters, if they are lucky, will get signed as undrafted free agents and play on the scout team for a year or two.