Philo Stay or Go Thread

Interviewing and accepting a new job mid-season is not ethical. If Brent knew, he should have removed Buster immediately.

Recruiting existing players is despicable. This is a key reason he should have been released immediately.
That’s the nature of the business now. Those SA’s who left to go to UF wanted to play in BF’s system. Do you think they would have stayed had CBK let BF go when GT was 8-2? They would have left for UF after the season ended anyway. This isn’t anything new. Look at what Cignetti did when he left JMU for IU. 19+ players went to IU with him. I think 16 players went with Campbell from ISU to PSU. Franklin landed quite a few players who left PSU for VT. It’s a relationship business, and until the new 5 for 5 and or 1 time transfer rule without sitting a year is in place, every player is really on a 1 year contract.

Heck, last year former UCLA HC Foster had to show a video on the importance of the USC game as the “hated” rival with all the new transfer players coming in.

Just a different era of CFB. The SA’s don’t really have that invested hatred towards rivals. Hopefully that changes when the new rules are put in place.

GT is perfectly fine. Based on all reports the talent level across the board is much better than this time last year. In CBK I trust.
 
That’s the nature of the business now. Those SA’s who left to go to UF wanted to play in BF’s system. Do you think they would have stayed had CBK let BF go when GT was 8-2? They would have left for UF after the season ended anyway. This isn’t anything new. Look at what Cignetti did when he left JMU for IU. 19+ players went to IU with him. I think 16 players went with Campbell from ISU to PSU. Franklin landed quite a few players who left PSU for VT. It’s a relationship business, and until the new 5 for 5 and or 1 time transfer rule without sitting a year is in place, every player is really on a 1 year contract.

Heck, last year former UCLA HC Foster had to show a video on the importance of the USC game as the “hated” rival with all the new transfer players coming in.

Just a different era of CFB. The SA’s don’t really have that invested hatred towards rivals. Hopefully that changes when the new rules are put in place.

GT is perfectly fine. Based on all reports the talent level across the board is much better than this time last year. In CBK I trust.
Recruiting after you leave is fine. Recruiting during the season while you are still being paid by Tech is not.
 
Why does it matter? Whoever picked it up, it was not his strength. So if the implication is Key took over and sucked at being OC, I’m not sure how that’s pertinent. Key isn’t the OC and has a limited track record of being a shitty OC.

Why does it matter if it were Narrative 1, 2, 3 or x?
 
Recruiting after you leave is fine. Recruiting during the season while you are still being paid by Tech is not.
If your assumption is even remotely true, GT should be contacting the NCAA and reporting UF for tampering. BF was coaching at GT through the end of the regular season. Like it or not, this BF was sabotaging GT’s O is a myth. GT played 2 of the toughest games of the season to end the season, and it is what it is.

Iowa has to forfeit games from the 2023 season for phone calls to the former Cuse’ QB.

The fact that nothing has been insinuated by CBK, etc sort of says all I need to know.

 
My suspicion is a strong philosophical difference was brewing between CBF and CBK. Biggest evidence was our ineffectiveness in the red zone, particularly short yardage. CBK implied…rather said…as much in his first spring practice interview.

CBF comes from a spread background with a strong short passing game and easy-west style running attack. Less inside/outside zone run schemes unless read tag with Haynes. Never had a consistent vertical pass attack, which is a great counter for teams with a power run scheme. Think Friedgen….how many times did LilJoe hit Kelly or Dez over top!

I doubt CBK took over playcalling but can rest assured his message was heard by Weinke in the bowl game.

The thing I can’t figure out…who made the defensive adjustments for the UGA game? We looked completely different. Aggressive coverages and blitz schemes galore. I loved it.
 
The thing I can’t figure out…who made the defensive adjustments for the UGA game? We looked completely different. Aggressive coverages and blitz schemes galore. I loved it.
While I liked keep the mutts to a low score, I saw a Kirby Smart team that was just trying to run something vanilla to get the win. They had many opportunities to score on us. Our D definitely came to play (the energy level vs the mutt offense was easy to see), but they had zero worry about us scoring on offense. They played us like an annoying mid major that just wouldn’t roll over and take it.
 
While I liked keep the mutts to a low score, I saw a Kirby Smart team that was just trying to run something vanilla to get the win. They had many opportunities to score on us. Our D definitely came to play (the energy level vs the mutt offense was easy to see), but they had zero worry about us scoring on offense. They played us like an annoying mid major that just wouldn’t roll over and take it.

They were definitely trying to score and couldn’t. Their play calling wasn’t vanilla, it was to cut down on the chances of a turnover.
 
While I liked keep the mutts to a low score, I saw a Kirby Smart team that was just trying to run something vanilla to get the win. They had many opportunities to score on us. Our D definitely came to play (the energy level vs the mutt offense was easy to see), but they had zero worry about us scoring on offense. They played us like an annoying mid major that just wouldn’t roll over and take it.
That’s fair. Their O left a lot to be desired at the end of the year.

Would need to rewatch, but my recollection is we played a lot of aggressive man coverage with a good blitz scheme.
 
They were definitely trying to score and couldn’t. Their play calling wasn’t vanilla, it was to cut down on the chances of a turnover.
This. Regardless of how bad play calls were that game, the last thing they wanted was HK with the ball in his hands.
 
This. Regardless of how bad play calls were that game, the last thing they wanted was HK with the ball in his hands.

They didn’t want to give us a short field with King. One LB or safety out of place and he could gash them.
 
I think the dwags and especially Stockton watched that film of HK running all over them in 24 and their collective pea brains couldnt handle it. Stockton suddenly thought he had Kings speed and toughness and did some stupid s--t trying to outdo him.
 
Interviewing and accepting a new job mid-season is not ethical. If Brent knew, he should have removed Buster immediately.

Recruiting existing players is despicable. This is a key reason he should have been released immediately.
100%. This needs to be the lesson learned. NIL rules have changed the risk of losing players and team stability which jeopardizes season goals.

Coaches who interview for jobs during the season need to find their office belongings in a box sitting on North Avenue when they return.
 
100%. This needs to be the lesson learned. NIL rules have changed the risk of losing players and team stability which jeopardizes season goals.

Coaches who interview for jobs during the season need to find their office belongings in a box sitting on North Avenue when they return.

Spot flipping on. There is no room for disloyalty
 
Spot flipping on. There is no room for disloyalty
Your age is showing. We wouldn't have a highly rated QB and RB going into the season if "loyalty" was still considered a virtue. I read somewhere we picked up nearly a new OL and DL through the portal and look pretty stacked going into this season. We have a chance at a great season because a bunch of 'disloyal' guys chose to come play for GT/CBK (and $$) rather than be loyal.
 
Your age is showing. We wouldn't have a highly rated QB and RB going into the season if "loyalty" was still considered a virtue. I read somewhere we picked up nearly a new OL and DL through the portal and look pretty stacked going into this season. We have a chance at a great season because a bunch of 'disloyal' guys chose to come play for GT/CBK (and $$) rather than be loyal.

You don't understand, when a player comes to Tech, they're just making a smart 40 year decision. If a kid leaves Tech for somewhere else, they're being disloyal and are just interested in a quick buck.
 
Your age is showing. We wouldn't have a highly rated QB and RB going into the season if "loyalty" was still considered a virtue. I read somewhere we picked up nearly a new OL and DL through the portal and look pretty stacked going into this season. We have a chance at a great season because a bunch of 'disloyal' guys chose to come play for GT/CBK (and $$) rather than be loyal.
It’s not unreasonable to ask a group of coaches and players to commit 100% to a team for 9 straight months until the end of the season. That means no interviews, no phone calls, no testing the water.

What happened last year with a record hot start and a 1-4 finish was unfortunate. And I believe that was partly attributable to selfish job shopping during the season.
 
Your age is showing. We wouldn't have a highly rated QB and RB going into the season if "loyalty" was still considered a virtue. I read somewhere we picked up nearly a new OL and DL through the portal and look pretty stacked going into this season. We have a chance at a great season because a bunch of 'disloyal' guys chose to come play for GT/CBK (and $$) rather than be loyal.
The portal isn't open during the season for players and it shouldn't be open for coaches either. After the season is over, do what you gotta do but during the season, do your damn job.
 
The portal isn't open during the season for players and it shouldn't be open for coaches either. After the season is over, do what you gotta do but during the season, do your damn job.
You guys are forgetting CBK interviewed for jobs too, mid season. Yeah, maybe he'd never take one, and was just negotiating for more money. But we can't have rules for thee but not for me.
 
Back
Top