Ranking based on different criteria

andrew

Bobby Bonilla's Financial Planner
Joined
Jun 5, 2010
Messages
28,124
Pretty cool tool that lets you put in the criteria you think should go into rankings and calculate them based on those criteria. You can adjust how much each criterion counts for by sliding the bars.


I've got two ACC (smu and Miami) and two sec (Texas and U[sic]GA) in the field of 12. Bama just out.

 
I took this quiz last night and ended up with similar results as you in terms of ACC and SEC representation. I just took it again now and I must have changed one of my answers, because now I have Tennessee, Bama, and Ole Miss at #10-12.

I do think there's still some inherent bias with how the stats are cherry picked in the quiz, but I love the idea of taking the team brands out of the equation. I hate the idea of talent composite being used to determine rankings and also don't like predicted point spread being a decision metric. Both fall into the category of "why even play the game" IMO.
 
Screenshot 2024-12-03 101817.png


Boom. Got us in the playoffs pretty easily. Figured opponent's record and best win was my best bet and slid it around til I got us to 7. lol
 
Ooops. I cropped it out but this method also got...Stanford into the CFP.
Silly.png
 
Sadly, I had Alabama as last in and Miami as first out. I would prefer to reverse that. I had 4 from the SEC and Big 10, ND, and the conference champs from the ACC, Big 12 and Mountain West.
 
Sadly, I had Alabama as last in and Miami as first out. I would prefer to reverse that. I had 4 from the SEC and Big 10, ND, and the conference champs from the ACC, Big 12 and Mountain West.
It’s so weird that on a weekend the SEC had to prove their superiority in order to ensure as many CFP spots as possible both games with SEC officials had hugely pivotal and controversial calls.
 
Back
Top