New Era - “Bidding Wars”

Structural changes? Like what? Oh, I'm sorry high tech company. We took your funds and put it towards football. What? You're pulling future funds? Why?
You’re right. Georgia Tech is just a poor little school who will never be able to compete with all those smart rich schools like Georgia, Auburn, or Alabama. We should just accept our poverty and not ask questions.
 
You’re right. Georgia Tech is just a poor little school who will never be able to compete with all those smart rich schools like Georgia, Auburn, or Alabama. We should just accept our poverty and not ask questions.

No one's saying that we're a poor school that can't compete with those schools. We're saying our athletic department is poor and can't compete with those schools ADs.

You're not going to find too many people involved with Tech who will say, "Hey, Georgia Tech could be more like Georgia, Auburn, and Alabama if we mixed academic money with athletic money. Let's do it!"
 
Wait till ESPN, the real governing body of CFB, decides that the transfer portal needs to be immediate with no limits on how many times a kid transfers. SEC dirtbags will have their bagman recruiting the opponents players during pregame warmups. Games will be like a cross between a pickup game and a smash and grab.
 
Wait till ESPN, the real governing body of CFB, decides that the transfer portal needs to be immediate with no limits on how many times a kid transfers. SEC dirtbags will have their bagman recruiting the opponents players during pregame warmups. Games will be like a cross between a pickup game and a smash and grab.

sounds like that game where you take turns placing the pieces and each time you do it changes everything in a line with the one you placed

I just flat suck at that game.
 
Apparently TAMU bought their #1 2022 class for around $30M. Its amazing to me that TAMU boosters value recruiting so much as to spend $30M to acquire recruits. I mean dont they have anything else better to spend their money on? They are crazy.

 
Apparently TAMU bought their #1 2022 class for around $30M. Its amazing to me that TAMU boosters value recruiting so much as to spend $30M to acquire recruits. I mean dont they have anything else better to spend their money on? They are crazy.

This will be an annual expense that will build up. Until the player uses his free transfer, they can reopen the bidding each year. On the other hand, if the player fails to perform or gets injured the NIL will disappear. This will be more wide open than the NFL.
The optimal strategy is to focus NIL funds on transfers with a proven track record.
 
The optimum strategy is performance based NIL contracts. Pay for performance. Can’t beat it. Poor performers get very little and possibly leave, whereas high performers make bank and have no incentive to look elsewhere.
 
The optimum strategy is performance based NIL contracts. Pay for performance. Can’t beat it. Poor performers get very little and possibly leave, whereas high performers make bank and have no incentive to look elsewhere.
My understanding is that performance based NIL's are not allowed.
 
NIL feels like it has missed the point, which was to allow athletes to make money off their fame while they are famous. With exceptions of a few already-famous HS 5-stars, nearly 100% of these recruits are unheard of except for the top 300 recruiting lists. You probably dont even know what they look like even if you know their name, thus anyone who signs them as a spokesperson is not getting any advertising value. NIL is now obviously just legal bagmen. I dont know how you can fix this so it goes back to what it should be and that is college stars getting to earn money off their fleeting fame while they have it, but it should not be a recruiting tool like it is. College football is absolutely trainwrecked.
 
NIL feels like it has missed the point, which was to allow athletes to make money off their fame while they are famous. With exceptions of a few already-famous HS 5-stars, nearly 100% of these recruits are unheard of except for the top 300 recruiting lists. You probably dont even know what they look like even if you know their name, thus anyone who signs them as a spokesperson is not getting any advertising value. NIL is now obviously just legal bagmen. I dont know how you can fix this so it goes back to what it should be and that is college stars getting to earn money off their fleeting fame while they have it, but it should not be a recruiting tool like it is. College football is absolutely trainwrecked.
Yeah... the idea that a famous player like a Trevor Lawrence could earn some money on like a Hardee's commercial has quickly devolved into I'll pay you $500K to leave your current team to play on my team. It's total horseshit. College athletics, and college football in particular, is in the most embarassing state within my lifetime. I have essentially no interest in watching any of it outside of GT... and I'm concerned that may be waning.
 
My understanding is that performance based NIL's are not allowed.
Right. That would make them an employee of the NCAA and then the whole "non-profit" house comes crashing down into the IRS ocean. I think the performance based contracts suggested in this thread, though, meant more that a player should earn their NIL by first becoming a star, and then profiting off his stardom. The highly recruited player than never cracked third string would just never get an NIL contract, instead setting for his $100K scholarship (oh, poor thing).
 
Right. That would make them an employee of the NCAA and then the whole "non-profit" house comes crashing down into the IRS ocean. I think the performance based contracts suggested in this thread, though, meant more that a player should earn their NIL by first becoming a star, and then profiting off his stardom. The highly recruited player than never cracked third string would just never get an NIL contract, instead setting for his $100K scholarship (oh, poor thing).
The model is NIL for highly rated freshman. Those will go away if they do not perform. At the same use NIL money to raid the top performers at other schools. This is not exactly pay for performance but it is close. The pay disappears if you do not perform.
 
No telling what this will devolve to in this day and age. Big windfall money and 18 year olds is a bad combo. There will be so many stories of kids who had big $$$$ who are back on the street broke and mentally anguished from it. Lots of MC Hammer stories.
 
No telling what this will devolve to in this day and age. Big windfall money and 18 year olds is a bad combo. There will be so many stories of kids who had big $$$$ who are back on the street broke and mentally anguished from it. Lots of MC Hammer stories.
That’s the only good I see coming from this.

Some player is going to throw the best
Coke party ever.
 
The model is NIL for highly rated freshman. Those will go away if they do not perform. At the same use NIL money to raid the top performers at other schools. This is not exactly pay for performance but it is close. The pay disappears if you do not perform.
I suppose the one thing I dont understand is the structure of these NIL contracts. So if TAMU promises a 5-star QB a $1M/year NIL deal, youre saying they get nothing if they dont make the field? I assumed the first year money is already earned just by signing your name. Yearly deals after that are then based upon performance, at least I thought.
 
Yep, this whole NIL and transfer portal is heading in a direction, as I thought it would, that will make the insignificant teams even more insignificant. Sad really.
 
Last edited:
I suppose the one thing I dont understand is the structure of these NIL contracts. So if TAMU promises a 5-star QB a $1M/year NIL deal, youre saying they get nothing if they dont make the field? I assumed the first year money is already earned just by signing your name. Yearly deals after that are then based upon performance, at least I thought.
They get the first year money for signing. The 2nd year NIL is based on the first year performance. However the player is free to transfer to another school with a better offer. The player has leverage assuming he performs until he transfers the first time.
 
Back
Top