4 system playoff needs to go to 8

GSUsTALON

GSUsTALON

Flats Noob
Joined
Sep 9, 2014
Messages
589
With #3 Georgia and #4 Bamma winning it shows the flaw in ***(picking)"" #1 & #2 to play for a NC.
Still the top 4 are picked for the playoffs

The NCAA needs to set up a system of 8 teams. The first 5 are the p5 conference champs & are not picked by some poll. The last three are open bids for the best of the rest.

The first 4 games are played at the top 4's home field. The rest of the playoffs are at a rotating bowl system as they are now. No need to go higher than 8 teams because the best teams are covered.
 
Unlike FCS, D2 & D3, P5 schools have bowls for teams with a winning season.

I doubt the P5 schools would want G5 schools involved.
 
ESPN seems happy about the outcome.

http://www.espn.com/college-footbal...e-football-playoff-title-game-come-true-again

Skip-Bayless.jpg
 
GSUsTALON said:
With #3 Georgia and #4 Bamma winning it shows the flaw in ***(picking)"" #1 & #2 to play for a NC.
Still the top 4 are picked for the playoffs

The NCAA needs to set up a system of 8 teams. The first 5 are the p5 conference champs & are not picked by some poll. The last three are open bids for the best of the rest.

The first 4 games are played at the top 4's home field. The rest of the playoffs are at a rotating bowl system as they are now. No need to go higher than 8 teams because the best teams are covered.
Click to expand...
This is my ideal system, except I would guarantee one of the last three slots to a G5 conference champ.

Four is still better than two though.
 
GSUsTALON said:
With #3 Georgia and #4 Bamma winning it shows the flaw in ***(picking)"" #1 & #2 to play for a NC.
Still the top 4 are picked for the playoffs

The NCAA needs to set up a system of 8 teams. The first 5 are the p5 conference champs & are not picked by some poll. The last three are open bids for the best of the rest.

The first 4 games are played at the top 4's home field. The rest of the playoffs are at a rotating bowl system as they are now. No need to go higher than 8 teams because the best teams are covered.
Click to expand...

Makes sense... which is why the NCAA will not allow it in the near future.
 
GSUsTALON said:
With #3 Georgia and #4 Bamma winning it shows the flaw in ***(picking)"" #1 & #2 to play for a NC.
Still the top 4 are picked for the playoffs

The NCAA needs to set up a system of 8 teams. The first 5 are the p5 conference champs & are not picked by some poll. The last three are open bids for the best of the rest.

The first 4 games are played at the top 4's home field. The rest of the playoffs are at a rotating bowl system as they are now. No need to go higher than 8 teams because the best teams are covered.
Click to expand...
Totally disagree
 
GSUsTALON said:
With #3 Georgia and #4 Bamma winning it shows the flaw in ***(picking)"" #1 & #2 to play for a NC.
Still the top 4 are picked for the playoffs

The NCAA needs to set up a system of 8 teams. The first 5 are the p5 conference champs & are not picked by some poll. The last three are open bids for the best of the rest.

The first 4 games are played at the top 4's home field. The rest of the playoffs are at a rotating bowl system as they are now. No need to go higher than 8 teams because the best teams are covered.
Click to expand...

1 and 2 should get a bye IMO
 
There's 32 teams in the NFL and approximately a third of them go to the playoffs every year over 4 rounds. There's never going to be 1 answer that makes college football fans happy. More teams means more games and those are games with unpaid players that go deeper into winter. Cutting games out of the schedule to accommodate more playoffs likely isn't going to happen because of all of the money that flows from FBS down in the OOC slate. You might could go to 8 and still have the big games on New Years Eve, but we're already going into the second week of January and more games means going closer to February. No heated fields in college football, so do you play all of your games in pro stadiums for playoffs while pro stadiums are competing for their own playoff slots?
 
Think it should left at 4 teams for now, but only if they are the conference champ.

If there is a controversy, let it be from the selection committee having the authority to invite an undeafeated team (such as ucf this year) over a team that is not a conference champ that has losses. JMO.

More concerned with GT.

Would like to know what Peterson’s & TStans goals are for GT on the field. Is it to beat uva or beat uga?
 
andrew said:
Wouldn't that leave you with three teams after the first round? Or do you want to go to six teams?
Click to expand...


Of course you are right. Would prefer six teams. I think the system that the NFL has set up to determine NFC and AFC champions is pretty good.
 
texstinger said:
Think it should left at 4 teams for now, but only if they are the conference champ.

If there is a controversy, let it be from the selection committee having the authority to invite an undeafeated team (such as ucf this year) over a team that is not a conference champ that has losses. JMO.

More concerned with GT.

Would like to know what Peterson’s & TStans goals are for GT on the field. Is it to beat uva or beat uga?
Click to expand...

Well said all around. Biggest problem right now is that a non-conference champ can get in. If conf champ doesn't matter to CFP, NCAA needs to do away with the championship games, full stop. But they never will because $$$ from additional game is too good.

6 or 8 teams would be step 2. No legitimate reason any undefeated FBS team should be left out of playoff scenario, unless you have 4 other undefeated FBS teams ranked ahead of them.

And yes, also more concerned with GT. Have seen a lot of positive off-the-field this offseason. This week will be big too, IMO (keeping McCollum? dumping Sewak?)
 
Make it 32....in the end, bama will still be in the final game regardless
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top