This is the wrong time of year to be talking about how CPJ compares to prior GT coaches... we got games to prepare for... mind rite etc. Nevertheless bc many on the board love this topic, here's my contribution...
We've played 51 seasons of football since Dodd retired (1967-2017) and had 9 coaches during that time.
The number of games the team plays has varied over the years, and now we typically play 50% more games each year than 100 years ago. So it seems fair to me not to look for 8+ win seasons or 9+ win seasons or 10+ win seasons, but rather to go by winning percentages.
Here are the ten best seasons (by winning percentage) since Dodd...
1990 Ross – 11-0-1 (0.958)
1998 O'Leary – 10-2-0 (0.833)
1985 Curry – 9-2-1 (0.792)
2014 CPJ – 11-3-0 (0.786)
2009 CPJ – 11-3-0 (0.786)
1970 Carson – 9-3-0 (0.750)
2000 O'Leary – 9-3-0 (0.750)
2008 CPJ – 9-4-0 (0.692)
2016 CPJ – 9-4-0 (0.692)
1999 O'Leary – 8-4-0 (0.667)
CCG's best season (2006 – 9-5-0 (.643)) comes in at #11 on the list.
So CCG's best season would be CPJ's fifth-best season. And while CPJ has coached 20% of our post-Dodd years, he's responsible for 40% of our best post-Dodd years.
We all agree that if we continue the downward trend of 2015-2017, then he's on the hot seat. But IMHO he's definitely earned the benefit of the doubt for now.
(As an aside, here's the average games played per season, per decade...
1910's – 8.6 games/yr
1920's – 9.2/yr
1930's – 10.0/yr
1940's – 10.4/yr
1950's – 11.1/yr
1960's – 10.4/yr
1970's – 11.4/yr
1980's – 11.1/yr
1990's – 11.6/yr
2000's – 12.8/yr
2010's – 12.9/yr)