Well, here's Dooley's records:
64 7-3-1
65 6-4
66 10-1 (tied with Bama for SEC championship)
67 7-4 (lost to Donnan in the Liberty Bowl)
68 8-1-2 (SEC champs, drilled by Arkansas in Sugar bowl)
69 5-5-1 (destroyed by Nebraska in Sun Bowl)
70 5-5
71 11-1 (beat brother Bill Dooley in Gator Bowl)
72 7-4
73 7-4-1
74 6-6
75 9-3
76 10-2 (won SEC, lost to Pitt in Sugar Bowl)
77 5-6 (only team he had with a losing record)
78 9-2-1 (luckiest team ever)
79 6-5
80 12-0 (hello, Herschel)
81 10-2
82 11-1
83 10-1-1 (goodbye, Herschel)
84 7-4-1 (lost to Tech for first time since 77)
85 9-2-1 (lost to Tech for first time since 84)
86 8-4
87 9-3
88 9-3
I don't know. He was a good coach with a few great teams scattered about over his tenure. I think he was better than some of us Tech fans give credit. But, I would not put him in the great category by any means. The 80-83 years with Herschel and the one year after Herschel were his best string by far. Outside of that, he was a good coach. It's weird to me how he won 2 SEC titles in his first 5 years and then things kinda fell off for a while. From 69 through 74, he only had one really good team ('71). I wonder why he couldn't keep them up to the level of 66 and 68?
Anyway...Dodd was better, I thought.