did we waist any redshirts last year?
- Thread starter gt23eric
- Start date
Wreck02
Damn Good Rat
- Joined
- Jul 12, 2007
- Messages
- 1,347
Yeah Marcus was important late. I thought it was a mistake to burn his RS but I think he was partially responsible for at least 2-3 TDs and the fumble recovery in the Georgie game (he was underneath Samuel's right knee so when the ball came out, he wasn't down)
supertech1984
Flats Noob
- Joined
- Apr 9, 2007
- Messages
- 828
I can't take it! Sorry to do this: Waste
On a separate note, naw, I feel good about where we are. We are going to staked at A-back I think. And without Marcus, we might not of won the UGA game, and that would be something I wouldn't take back for the world!
On a separate note, naw, I feel good about where we are. We are going to staked at A-back I think. And without Marcus, we might not of won the UGA game, and that would be something I wouldn't take back for the world!
LambdaChiGT
Dodd-Like
- Joined
- Sep 12, 2008
- Messages
- 4,660
stacked?
olgoldandwhite
Dodd-Like
- Joined
- Dec 9, 2005
- Messages
- 2,591
The only way you can "waste" a redshirt, is you have to assume that in 4 years you will not have a player any better than an assumed 4 year starter that will never get injured, go pro, or leave the program. I can't predict tomorrow, much less 4 years from now.:D
law_bee
Dodd-Like
- Joined
- Nov 25, 2001
- Messages
- 6,402
redshirts are overrated for skill players. Just like with knowshow he was redshirted and then ONLY played 3 years.
Lineman (or players that need more size) need to be redshirted.
The reality is IT IS VERY UNLIKELY that 3 years from now we will be lamenting the fact that Marcus is graduating.
We will be taking A-backs for the next 3 years and UNLESS we have SOME SERIOUS injuries his TOP value will be in his early part of his college career. IMO
Lineman (or players that need more size) need to be redshirted.
The reality is IT IS VERY UNLIKELY that 3 years from now we will be lamenting the fact that Marcus is graduating.
We will be taking A-backs for the next 3 years and UNLESS we have SOME SERIOUS injuries his TOP value will be in his early part of his college career. IMO
Why do you think that? You think he won't improve or just that we will bring in players that much better?
WaCoJacket
Varsity Lurker
- Joined
- Dec 3, 2007
- Messages
- 337
The delta between Marcus and the next available guy will be higher in year 1/2 of the offense than in subsequent years. We had a FB playing A-Back last year. Next year this time, we'll have Jemea Thomas, Orwin Smith, Charles Perkins, Jamal Paige, etc behind Marcus. With Roddy, Allen, and/or Peeples ahead on on par with Marcus.
floridajacket
The Real DB Cooper
- Joined
- Oct 14, 2005
- Messages
- 17,799
There's also the possibility that if the team really needs it, a player can redshirt a year other than freshman year, like Phillip Wheeler did.
I would say we needed to burn the redshirts we did last year because we were pretty shallow all around last year. If one of the players on the kicking team had been redshirted instead, we would have had to risk a starter on kickoff return.
I would say we needed to burn the redshirts we did last year because we were pretty shallow all around last year. If one of the players on the kicking team had been redshirted instead, we would have had to risk a starter on kickoff return.
D
Damarius
Guest
Marcus Wright was NOT a wasted redshirt.
He was CRUCIAL in the Georgia Game, as he recovered the huge fumble to set up Dwyer's go-ahead TD in the 3rd quarter. We went from 28-12 with 15:00 to 35-28 with 7:00 - Truly unbelievable.
Think about that:
14:55 Georgia - 28 Georgia Tech - 12
7:05 Georgia Tech - 35 Georgia - 28
Simply amazing...
He was CRUCIAL in the Georgia Game, as he recovered the huge fumble to set up Dwyer's go-ahead TD in the 3rd quarter. We went from 28-12 with 15:00 to 35-28 with 7:00 - Truly unbelievable.
Think about that:
14:55 Georgia - 28 Georgia Tech - 12
7:05 Georgia Tech - 35 Georgia - 28
Simply amazing...