I'm clicking around on Scout on ND's past recruits. A lot of them did have offers from schools like USC, Oklahoma, Florida, etc. But there are also 4*, highly ranked recruits which have mediocre offer lists, schools like Kentucky, Iowa, Indiana, and no mention of a powerhouse offer.
Most of these overrated recruits also are on defense. So it does seem like they have MSU and Indiana level talent on defense. Nevertheless, there's no excuse for how bad Weis has done. I never got what was so impressive about an NFL assistant. His fat ass must have given a hell of an interview.
Kelly took a program that was nothing to a perfect season. He will be very successful at ND. Maybe not multiple MNC's like they were hoping for Weis, but he'll have plenty of 10+ win seasons with their cupcake schedule.