He had a really good line blocking for him, too.
Go look at his stats. Yes, he had a good year but not a first team All-American year (1,253 yds- 11 TDs).
He averaged 4.8 ypc.
The reason he got so much credit, though, was because of his great game against USC which also happened to be his highest output of the season.
I'm not trying to downplay the guy but from what I saw, he's not the first team AA. He's second or third.
Also, I disagree that Dwyer has a worse year statistically. People sold out last year to stop the dive and he still ended up with 1,400 yards at 7 ypc behind a patchwork OL. If things go as planned, the OL will be better this year, thus meaning he will have a better seam to hit when the dive is ran.
This all IMO, of course.