I was just thinking about this. In our first couple of years with some serious NFL talent on offense plus a beast at QB, we had an unbelievable dive play and QB keeper, but it seemed like we were either three and out or a 1 or 2 play TD drive. Then came Tevin and it just didnt seem to click like before but at least we could sustain drives without a huge amount of big plays like before. Then the Vad Lee experiment seemed to get us away from our base offense and it didnt work out too well. Finally, Justin Thomas was the dynamic playmaker we thought would thrive in this offense but his best year seemed to be his first year (year three wasn't too bad either). However, the point is the offense was both explosive and sustained drives while third and long no longer seemed utterly impossible.
The offense is clearly different but I cant put my finger on it. Help?
If you think Tevin didn't click, you clearly weren't paying attention.
The offense varied based on QB.
Nesbitt, everything keyed off the midline. We ran the triple, but how the linebackers set up for the midline was what we based our adjustments off of, because the midline was a guaranteed 4 yards, and a shitpile on cutbacks. The 08 offense was midline, triple, B Back speed option as our staples. The midline evolution by the 09 ACCCG included firing an A back into the midline gap, something I've never seen Navy do.
With Tevin, we ran less midline unless there was an obvious need, and CPJ got a little more timid with 4th down conversions. Tevin ran the reads of the triple better than any other QB we've had, and our offense looked the most like Navy that I've seen us run. Tevin was also wicked good at QB draws.
Vad couldn't make the line reads to run the triple with velocity. We evolved our offense around rocket-toss, rocket-action-pass. Wait, what was that? I think we just scored on UNC again.
JT14 we started truly exploiting rollouts, designed QB keepers, and run pass options, purely to capitalize on JT's speed. Then we'd pair that with zone dives into the boundary behind Shaq. In some ways, that's a lot like what NFL teams do, or Big 10 teams do. We kept the rocket to force them to scheme the rocket, and then once they were lined up to stop the rocket we'd zone dive them to catch the firing CB out of position. That's like the entire story of the 14 wins over UGA and Miss St.
JT15 nothing worked because our perimeter blockers would pick clovers and stick their fingers up their butts at the snap.
JT16 was similar in some ways to JT14, but with less talent at WR and no Shaq.
If we go with Matthew Jordan next year, expect a shift back to midline as the base play. He better work on his passing, though, or it'll be a long year.