NC, good points. I am as close to seeing it your way as anything on this thread.
However, now that the other shoe has dropped, I think its OK to now say that Chan was not that naieve to believe that his staying out of academic progress of his players was in any way acceptable.
That condition was just part of the job description and he accepted it. I have much more faith in the intelligence of Chan Gailey to believe anything else.
We were in a compliance mess because of laziness and lack of communication.
CG will now be very active (publicly) making sure his kids go to class, as he would have if DB hadn't played Spy vs Spy.