Thanks Cycle Jacket, I really enjoy talking football with you guys.
This is going to sound a little bizarre, but I've studied leadership on various levels for a number of years and one intangible that all good leaders have is a "look" that exudes confidence and inspires people around them to jump through fire. I never liked Donnan because of the way he presented himself on and off the field. He had the face of a sour puss. He never had the eyes of a great leader and he never demanded the type of effort required to win championships at a SEC level. Discipline was a four letter word to Donnan, hence all the player violations and trouble surrounding the program. Unfortunately for Tech, Gailey has that same type of look about him. His mannerisms don't provide the presense of a leader. He couldn't get it done in Dallas because he isn't a 4 star general. Like Donnan he is a decent X's & O's coach who understands all aspects of the game, but neither man has the intangible leadership qualities that set them apart from guys like Spurrier, Bowden, Osborne, Paterno and many other winners.
Mark Richt isn't Einstein, but he has tremendous character and a fire in his eyes. He knows all the nuances of building a national championship program because he learned it from one of the greatest of all time in Bobby Bowden. Richt is a 4 star general because he expects to win and knows how to inspire his players to believe they can win against any opponent under any circumstance. It may not always happen, but the important part is to get the players to believe that they should expect to win. Richt is calm and cool under pressure, which is an extremely important quality in a leader. A lot of Tech fans are mad at Gailey because he stood off to the side and didn't get in the face mask of his players. Yelling and screaming looks good on TV, but in the long run it breeds contempt. There is a difference between detachment and being cool under pressure, in the later you are continuously engaged but are in control.
IMO, Braine made a mistake when he hired Gailey. I think he will do a good job of keeping you competitive in the ACC, but I really don't believe he will bring a National Championship to Tech. One look at his face and it is obvious... like I said it sounds strange.