#14 - K - Aidan Birr - Kennedale TX

I imagine its tougher for kickers to get schollies the next four years as teams have to deal with an extra class of scholarship players hanging around due to the extra year of eligibility but the same overall cap limit going forward next year?
 
His kicks form 60 yards look better than extra point attempts for the past two years .

Kicking 60 yarders in practice with nobody rushing is completely different than in a real time situation with the game on the line and the other team rushing the ball.

I need another reason to be impressed. What were his stats in real games? Maybe that was posted and I missed it.

I want to be excited but we've whiffed too many times in recent years on these kickers.
 
Kicking 60 yarders in practice with nobody rushing is completely different than in a real time situation with the game on the line and the other team rushing the ball.

I need another reason to be impressed. What were his stats in real games? Maybe that was posted and I missed it.

I want to be excited but we've whiffed too many times in recent years on these kickers.
You saw who we had the last two years. It was imperative we grab another leg or two.
 
Kicking 60 yarders in practice with nobody rushing is completely different than in a real time situation with the game on the line and the other team rushing the ball.
True, and it’s hard to judge the angle of those kicks to see if they’d be blocked.

But I’ll take a guy who can kick 60 yarders in practice over someone who can’t. Our guys since Butker can’t.
 
Based on our current recruiting success I see no reason why this dude won't be good. We have recruiters folks. Times they are a changin'.
 
Kicking 60 yarders in practice with nobody rushing is completely different than in a real time situation with the game on the line and the other team rushing the ball.

I need another reason to be impressed. What were his stats in real games? Maybe that was posted and I missed it.

I want to be excited but we've whiffed too many times in recent years on these kickers.

Stats don't really tell you much about High School kickers, either. 6 of 8 on FGs, 63 of 66 on XPs.
 
Sure, but giving him a scholly?
Switch places with the kicker. Are you going to come to GT and pay your own way with out-of-state tuition? So the staff figures the kid stands a good shot at being really good. So they roll the dice and offer a scholly to lock him up.

Maybe it works/maybe it don't. Let's let it play out.
 
We couldn’t even make a 26 yard field goal last year…repeatedly. And you’re worried that we may have wasted a scholly? lol
Exactly. Why fans don’t understand the importance of a kicker is mind blowing. Bama almost lost a Natty because of a kicker against UGA no less. Having a legit kicker is more important than several other positions. Butker won many games for GT and we have been dreadful ever sense. Field position is all about kickers. We put our defense in holes when we can’t simply kick it into the end zone. We have gobs of players on scholarship at wide receiver and DB, many of whom will rarely see the field, yet a position that is on the field throughout the game and puts points on the board shouldn’t be on a scholly? Heck, I wouldn’t whine about having 2-3 kickers on scholly instead of yet another DB who will enter the portal when his boys convince him he’s the next Deion.
 
Butker won many games for GT…
harrison-butker-georgia-tech.jpg


Ranks above my wedding and about equal with the birth of my children for greatest moment of my life.
 
We couldn’t even make a 26 yard field goal last year…repeatedly. And you’re worried that we may have wasted a scholly? lol

I read somewhere that less than 1% of kickers end up earning a scholarship. I don't know whether that stat is true or not. What I do know is that the norm is bringing in kickers as walkons and letting them earn the scholly through their play. So what I'm asking is what this particular kicker has done to earn a scholly right off the bat.

It's a legit question and "I trust the coaching staff!!!!!!!!11" and "you're a kicker hater!" are not responses that garner thoughtful discussion.
 
I read somewhere that less than 1% of kickers end up earning a scholarship. I don't know whether that stat is true or not. What I do know is that the norm is bringing in kickers as walkons and letting them earn the scholly through their play. So what I'm asking is what this particular kicker has done to earn a scholly right off the bat.

It's a legit question and "I trust the coaching staff!!!!!!!!11" and "you're a kicker hater!" are not responses that garner thoughtful discussion.
Why don’t you ask the same question for the 15 DB’s and 10 WR’s who have schollies? The only person who can authorize a scholarship is the head coach. So “I trust the coaching staff” is the only answer because not one of us can see what is going on in the head coaches head. And the reason that 1% of kickers get scholarships (if that is true) and has become the “norm”is because generally football coaches are meat heads who don’t fully understand where wins come from. If you look at GT’s football history, at least the last 50 years, the years we had special seasons were all tied to kickers. Without Scott Sisson the only argument GT fans can win wouldn’t exist (1980). We had great kickers during the O’Leary run. And of course Butker. As I mentioned earlier I’d offer 2-3 kickers a scholarship and then send the ones who cant hack it to the portal. No different than what Collins has done with other positions. But then we get into the whole “you shouldn’t rescind scholarships” argument from the purists who love mediocrity.
 
I read somewhere that less than 1% of kickers end up earning a scholarship. I don't know whether that stat is true or not. What I do know is that the norm is bringing in kickers as walkons and letting them earn the scholly through their play. So what I'm asking is what this particular kicker has done to earn a scholly right off the bat.

It's a legit question and "I trust the coaching staff!!!!!!!!11" and "you're a kicker hater!" are not responses that garner thoughtful discussion.

Maybe it went something like this...


Aidan Birr’s first visit to Atlanta was for Georgia Tech’s camp for specialists in June...

After an impressive performance at the camp and a month of communication, Birr was offered a scholarship Tuesday...

Birr was connected to Tech through his high-school coach’s relationship with Yellow Jackets running backs coach Tashard Choice, which led to him attending the specialists camp.

While he couldn’t recall how many kicks he attempted that day, Birr remembered missing only two or three. Along with his kickoffs, it was evidently a performance that convinced Tech coaches to pursue him. Birr said he has been communicating the most with cornerbacks coach Jeff Popovich, who also coaches special teams.
 
Back
Top