You're probably splitting hairs when you get to the top of the rankings.
I'd rather live in Athens than Tuscaloosa.
The GA recruiting base is obviously elite, and UGA is the flagship of the state.
UGA fan base probably isn't as crazy as the Bama fan base. From a coaching perspective, that is good because it gives you a little more job security. But if I was ranking programs from an objective, non-coach's perspective, it's probably bad, because you're willing to accept Mark Richt far longer than you should. I mean, what does it say about the UGA fan base that Miami seems to have put the kind of screws to Richt after only three seasons that caused him to resign, while UGA accepted it for how long?
Proof of concept easily favors Bama. Say whatever you want to about all the advantages UGA has, they still don't have much to show for it. While arguably the two most successful coaches in college football history are at one school, and they are decades apart.