Coaching Hire Grades - CBS

BuzzinWreck78

BuzzinWreck78

Dodd-Like
Joined
Jun 12, 2021
Messages
2,627
Chadwell A-
Sanders A-
Rhule A
Freeze A
Fickle A+
herman B
Key B-
Satterfield C+
golesh D
beck F
Dillingham C+
Dilfer C-
.
Key led the Yellow Jackets to a 4-4 record following Collins' dismissal. He's a Georgia Tech alum who knows the challenges that the program faces. With that said, he's a first-time head coach at a Power Five school that has to fight recruiting battles with all of the top-tier teams in the country. It might take some time. Grade: B-
.
more at link
www.cbssports.com

College football coaching carousel: Tracker, analysis, grades on coach changes, 2022-23 hires

The 2022-23 coaching carousel is rolling along as Bowl Season has arrived
www.cbssports.com www.cbssports.com
 
Diseqc said:
These are always funny for a giggle a few years down the road

Click to expand...
scott-frost-nebraska-cornhuskers-football.jpg


You could make a pretty successful blog just rewinding sports media a few years and lolling.
 
Diseqc said:
These are always funny for a giggle a few years down the road

Click to expand...

2018 Ranking - Hiring Grade - Result
1. Scott Frost, Nebraska - A+ , Fired (16-31)
2. Dan Mullen, Florida - A , Fired (34-15)
3. Chip Kelly, UCLA - A , Mixed but still there (27-28)
4. Jimbo Fisher, Texas A&M - A- , Unfire-able. Civil Unrest (29-21)
5. Willie Taggart, Florida State - A- , Fired (9-12)
6. Joe Moorhead, Mississippi State - B+ , Fired (14-12)
7. Chad Morris, Arkansas - B+ , Fired (4-18)
8. Kevin Sumlin, Arizona - B , Fired (9-20)
9. Jeremy Pruitt, Tennessee - B , Fired (16-19)
10. Steve Campbell, South Alabama - B , Fired (9-26)
11. Billy Napier, Louisiana - B- , PROMOTED (40-12)
12. Sonny Dykes, SMU - B- , PROMOTED (30-18)
13. Mario Cristobal, Oregon - B- , PROMOTED (35-13)
14. Jonathan Smith, Oregon State - C+ , Mixed but still there. (25-31)
15. Matt Luke, Ole Miss - C , Fired (15-21)
16. Josh Heupel, UCF - C , PROMOTED (28-8)
17. Mike Bloomgren, Rice - C , Bad but still there (16-38)
18. Sean Lewis, Kent State - C , Mixed but still there (24-31)
19. Chad Lunsford, Georgia Southern - C- , Fired (28-21)
20. Dana Dimel, UTEP - D , Bad but still there (17-40)
21. Herm Edwards, Arizona State - D- , Fired (26-20)

Some interesting notes from this:
1. Only 2 of the the top 10 rated hires are still coaching where they were hired. Chip Kelly and Jimbo.
2. 4 of these 21 coaches found "promotions". All had a hiring grade of B- or worse.
3. Only 6 of these 21 are still there. Of these 6 only 1 has a winning record- Jimbo.
4. 11 of the 21 were fired. 4 were promoted. 5 are still there with losing records. 1 is still there with a winning record.
 
Buzzilla said:
2018 Ranking Hiring Grade Result
1. Scott Frost, Nebraska A+ Fired (16-31)
2. Dan Mullen, Florida A Fired (34-15)
3. Chip Kelly, UCLA A Mixed but still there (27-28)
4. Jimbo Fisher, Texas A&M A- Unfire-able. Civil Unrest (29-21)
5. Willie Taggart, Florida State A- Fired (9-12)
6. Joe Moorhead, Mississippi State B+ Fired (14-12)
7. Chad Morris, Arkansas B+ Fired (4-18)
8. Kevin Sumlin, Arizona B Fired (9-20)
9. Jeremy Pruitt, Tennessee B Fired (16-19)
10. Steve Campbell, South Alabama B Fired (9-26)
11. Billy Napier, Louisiana B- PROMOTED (40-12)
12. Sonny Dykes, SMU B- PROMOTED (30-18)
13. Mario Cristobal, Oregon B- PROMOTED (35-13)
14. Jonathan Smith, Oregon State C+ Mixed but still there. (25-31)
15. Matt Luke, Ole Miss C Fired (15-21)
16. Josh Heupel, UCF C PROMOTED (28-8)
17. Mike Bloomgren, Rice C Bad but still there (16-38)
18. Sean Lewis, Kent State C Mixed but still there (24-31)
19. Chad Lunsford, Georgia Southern C- Fired (28-21)
20. Dana Dimel, UTEP D Bad but still there (17-40)
21. Herm Edwards, Arizona State D- Fired (26-20)

Some interesting notes from this:
1. Only 2 of the the top 10 rated hires are still coaching where they were hired. Chip Kelly and Jimbo.
2. 4 of these 21 coaches found "promotions". All had a hiring grade of B- or worse.
3. Only 6 of these 21 are still there. Of these 6 only 1 has a winning record- Jimbo.
4. 11 of the 21 were fired. 4 were promoted. 5 are still there with losing records. 1 is still there with a winning record.
Click to expand...
Most coaches are hired to be fired
 
Buzzilla said:
2018 Ranking - Hiring Grade - Result
1. Scott Frost, Nebraska - A+ , Fired (16-31)
2. Dan Mullen, Florida - A , Fired (34-15)
3. Chip Kelly, UCLA - A , Mixed but still there (27-28)
4. Jimbo Fisher, Texas A&M - A- , Unfire-able. Civil Unrest (29-21)
5. Willie Taggart, Florida State - A- , Fired (9-12)
6. Joe Moorhead, Mississippi State - B+ , Fired (14-12)
7. Chad Morris, Arkansas - B+ , Fired (4-18)
8. Kevin Sumlin, Arizona - B , Fired (9-20)
9. Jeremy Pruitt, Tennessee - B , Fired (16-19)
10. Steve Campbell, South Alabama - B , Fired (9-26)
11. Billy Napier, Louisiana - B- , PROMOTED (40-12)
12. Sonny Dykes, SMU - B- , PROMOTED (30-18)
13. Mario Cristobal, Oregon - B- , PROMOTED (35-13)
14. Jonathan Smith, Oregon State - C+ , Mixed but still there. (25-31)
15. Matt Luke, Ole Miss - C , Fired (15-21)
16. Josh Heupel, UCF - C , PROMOTED (28-8)
17. Mike Bloomgren, Rice - C , Bad but still there (16-38)
18. Sean Lewis, Kent State - C , Mixed but still there (24-31)
19. Chad Lunsford, Georgia Southern - C- , Fired (28-21)
20. Dana Dimel, UTEP - D , Bad but still there (17-40)
21. Herm Edwards, Arizona State - D- , Fired (26-20)

Some interesting notes from this:
1. Only 2 of the the top 10 rated hires are still coaching where they were hired. Chip Kelly and Jimbo.
2. 4 of these 21 coaches found "promotions". All had a hiring grade of B- or worse.
3. Only 6 of these 21 are still there. Of these 6 only 1 has a winning record- Jimbo.
4. 11 of the 21 were fired. 4 were promoted. 5 are still there with losing records. 1 is still there with a winning record.
Click to expand...
So much for their rating system. hmmmm
 
BuzzinWreck78 said:
Chadwell A-
Sanders A-
Rhule A
Freeze A
Fickle A+
herman B
Key B-
Satterfield C+
golesh D
beck F
Dillingham C+
Dilfer C-
.
Key led the Yellow Jackets to a 4-4 record following Collins' dismissal. He's a Georgia Tech alum who knows the challenges that the program faces. With that said, he's a first-time head coach at a Power Five school that has to fight recruiting battles with all of the top-tier teams in the country. It might take some time. Grade: B-
.
more at link
www.cbssports.com

College football coaching carousel: Tracker, analysis, grades on coach changes, 2022-23 hires

The 2022-23 coaching carousel is rolling along as Bowl Season has arrived
www.cbssports.com www.cbssports.com
Click to expand...
$100 Chadwell is a flop.
 
Dhatura said:
You can still get them in this day in age? I mean, I know they're still have some reserved for Tech, but for other schools...
Click to expand...

Ohio State and Bama will not suffer the recruits to go to Boulder.
 
BuzzinWreck78 said:
Chadwell A-
Sanders A-
Rhule A
Freeze A
Fickle A+
herman B
Key B-
Satterfield C+
golesh D
beck F
Dillingham C+
Dilfer C-
.
Key led the Yellow Jackets to a 4-4 record following Collins' dismissal. He's a Georgia Tech alum who knows the challenges that the program faces. With that said, he's a first-time head coach at a Power Five school that has to fight recruiting battles with all of the top-tier teams in the country. It might take some time. Grade: B-
.
more at link
www.cbssports.com

College football coaching carousel: Tracker, analysis, grades on coach changes, 2022-23 hires

The 2022-23 coaching carousel is rolling along as Bowl Season has arrived
www.cbssports.com www.cbssports.com
Click to expand...
One asshole's opinion. What makes it any better than yours or mine? What is his track record? Where was he on CGC four years ago? Did he slobber over Texas hiring Herman, like most of the media? Ditto Nebraska hiring Scott Frost?

How about the Vols hiring Heupel?

Forget about Key . . . just looking at some of the other grades makes me think he's full of öööö. Ruhle is an A? Really? Herman is a B . . . for FAU??? Does he know the first ööööing thing about FAU? Doubtful. ASU is a disaster zone . . . Dillingham was a steal for them.

So . . . I'm not impressed with these grades.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top