100% perfectly right. I made the same point earlier.
APR is a freaking excuse
Here is a fact. Historically we have more normal students that fail out with GREAT GPAs and GREAT SAT's than SA's. I can't think of one football SA that failed out in the past 7 years, and if one its one or two. I guarantee the normal student populous is higher than that. Secondly, when we DID allow exceptions we again, maybe 1 academic casualty a year, out of 85. That is still below the student populous and doesn't hurt APR much if any. Its a chance, we need to be still willing to take. And a small one
APR is a total excuse. Dabuzz is 100% correct on the history and exceptions were and are not a problem, nor never have been. What was, was oversight and support and it became an excuse for change to clamp down on athletics.