The state of NIL and the Transfer Portal is all the NCAA’s fault, that’s why. Had the NCAA implemented gate revenue sharing with the players even 5 years ago as CFB evolved into a billion dollar industry where HC’s are making $10+ million a year and AD’s are making millions, then P5 football wouldn’t be in the mess it’s in. Instead the NCAA relied on the Supreme Court to back them and instead the Supreme Court correctly blamed the NCAA and pretty much rendering the NCAA powerless.
NIL is here for good. The Transfer Portal can be fixed once the remaining P4 conferences eliminate the NCAA as the governing body and implement their own commissioner. Next should be:
1. Eliminate the stupidity known as APR. How this makes any sense now is a complete joke.
2. Setup Portal guardrails. Kids can enter at any time, but only between a certain designated time period once a year can they transfer.
3. Create guaranteed scholarships that both the player and school agree to and sign. Whether that’s 1, 2, 3, or 4 year which includes healthcare. This would help slow down the Portal nonsense.
4. Setup a team “salary cap” per se, where gate revenue is distributed evenly to the players on the team.
The gate revenue share doesn't have anything to do with NIL. NIL is not the kids fault businesses want to pay them. Good on the kids. Anyone who is upset about NIL needs to look at it from the players point of view.