No scheme expert here but I saw a lot of pitch plays out of shotgun. Maybe that’s because they want to throw more but have the ability to run those type of run based option plays. Very interestingWe are all hearing a lot of buzz around Chadwell as a potential HC candidate. Curious to know from the scheme gurus on this board on how his offense is that different from Monken's at Army or other triple option derivatives.
We are all hearing a lot of buzz around Chadwell as a potential HC candidate. Curious to know from the scheme gurus on this board on how his offense is that different from Monken's at Army or other triple option derivatives.
He is going to get a shot and is going to make this post look stupid.Chadwell is a big fish in a small pond.
He won’t last five minutes in the P5 ocean.
Don’t presume to know what I did or didn’t know in the mid 1980s. I was one of the boots on the ground at the time and I knew more than I will ever post here.He is going to get a shot and is going to make this post look stupid.
You probably would have said the same thing about friedgen's offense in the early 1980s.
Don’t presume to know what I did or didn’t know in the mid 1980s. I was one of the boots on the ground at the time and I knew more than I will ever post here.
If you think I’m off base about my view of Chadwell then fine. We can debate publicly in the Court of Stingtalk.
But don’t question my right to express an opinion in this forum. I paid my dues to Georgia Tech and I’ll put my resume up against your or anyone else’s anytime.
We are all hearing a lot of buzz around Chadwell as a potential HC candidate. Curious to know from the scheme gurus on this board on how his offense is that different from Monken's at Army or other triple option derivatives.
Don’t presume to know what I did or didn’t know in the mid 1980s. I was one of the boots on the ground at the time and I knew more than I will ever post here.
If you think I’m off base about my view of Chadwell then fine. We can debate publicly in the Court of Stingtalk.
But don’t question my right to express an opinion in this forum. I paid my dues to Georgia Tech and I’ll put my resume up against your or anyone else’s anytime.
I paid my dues to Georgia Tech and I’ll put my resume up against your or anyone else’s anytime.
I remember listening to an interview with Chadwell. He basically said that his offense looks a lot like the CPJ flexbone, but it didn't share any history. Basically it evolved some similar concepts but started from a completely different place.
I think Chadwell is a brilliant football coach. I just question if our boosters and (half of our) fans base can deal with another option coach.
Personally, I would love it.
/
Definitely check out a Coastal game before you make a judgement. It's a very cool system. I personally think it looks a lot more like a modern RPO (what you'll see today at Clemson and Bama) than CPJ's system. For one, there is a lot more passing in his system. But there are still some similarities under the surface to a traditional option attack.
TL;DR - I don't really understand lumping in Chadwell with the "pure option" crowd based on what I've seen so far, but I'm happy to go watch more tape.
There are those who find Bob Davie's commentary illuminating. Seems to me that Chadwell represents something we hoped Paul Johnson's tenure would lead towards, at least as far as on-field philosophy/scheming/"identity" are concerned.TL;DR - I don't really understand lumping in Chadwell with the "pure option" crowd based on what I've seen so far, but I'm happy to go watch more tape.
Any coach who runs one option play per game sadly gets lumped in like that by some.Definitely check out a Coastal game before you make a judgement. It's a very cool system. I personally think it looks a lot more like a modern RPO (what you'll see today at Clemson and Bama) than CPJ's system. For one, there is a lot more passing in his system. But there are still some similarities under the surface to a traditional option attack.
TL;DR - I don't really understand lumping in Chadwell with the "pure option" crowd based on what I've seen so far, but I'm happy to go watch more tape.
Definitely check out a Coastal game before you make a judgement. It's a very cool system. I personally think it looks a lot more like a modern RPO (what you'll see today at Clemson and Bama) than CPJ's system. For one, there is a lot more passing in his system. But there are still some similarities under the surface to a traditional option attack.
TL;DR - I don't really understand lumping in Chadwell with the "pure option" crowd based on what I've seen so far, but I'm happy to go watch more tape.
Sounds like what friedgen had Shawn Jones run to perfection. Defending friedgen was like playing whack a mole. No way to plug all the holes.Is it like what Pat White ran at West Virginia? So the Rich Rod offense?
It is an option offense just out of the shotgun but most people really only know enough to know that running your offense from under center is not cool.
Like how I have to bring along a half dozen of my buddies when I go to your mom's. Even then, rolls count as holes, and there are a lot left unplugged.Sounds like what friedgen had Shawn Jones run to perfection. Defending friedgen was like playing whack a mole. No way to plug all the holes.