It's hard to put anything above 2000. I was only 13 so the players were more like gods and monsters than kids to me. I remember being home alone and when Goose connected to Watkins I lost my mind and in the process flipped over the top of my dad's recliner, taking the chair with me. I'd felt terrible for Watkins since the end of the NC State game and he got his redemption ten times over. It's strange how out of place Godsey looked in that offense and on the field in general but his command of Fridge's offense was beautiful.
2004 was incredible but only there at the end with The Catch II. The rest of that game was agonizing outside of Calvin doing his thing.
2009 was, as someone else mentioned, awesome, then terrible, then awesome again.
The 2009 ACCCG is probably the closest thing to 2000's greatness. I've gone on at length on here about my experience that night, it was truly perfect. That feeling when Morgan got the sack to clinch it is a feeling I want more often. There are few things better than being there to see Tech win a championship.