I posted these stats early December, and had posted them assuming a UGAg bowl win... here they are again, updated with the loss:
1st 3 years Kirby vs. Richt
W-L Records
Kirby - 8-5, 13-2, 11-3 (32-10 total)
Richt - 8-4, 13-1, 11-3 (32-8 total)
SEC Championships
Kirby - 1
Richt - 1
5 yr W-L Before each arrived
pre-Kirby - 50-17 (10-3.4 average, 74.6 win%)
pre-Richt - 40-19 (8-3.8 average, 67.8 win%)
So which one improved upon the predecessor?
Richt started off with a 32-8 recored, 80.0 win%, 12.2% improvement over the previous 5 yr average.
Kirby has a 32-10 record, 76.2 win%, only 1.6% improvement over last 5 years, and still lower win% than Richt's first 3 seasons.
So, Kirby is slightly behind where Richt was at this point. Then comes the "but we made it to the playoffs and the Championship game in his 2nd season." Richt was 13-1 his second season with an SEC championship. He would've been in the playoffs. He also would've been there in '02, and possibly '12. All of Richt's success also came when Florida and Tennessee had solid programs, and Spurrier at USCe had the Dwags number. Now they are in the weakest SEC East there has ever been, and he is still Richt 2.0.