Who's In?

[ThisIsAtlanta]

Vote

 

[Keyser Soze]

OSU is in. Don't agree, just wish the playoff committee had specific parameters.

 

[PolyJacket]

Vote

Done

 

[ThisIsAtlanta]

Just realized I put Wisconsin in there. Oh well.

 

[ElCidBUZZingFAN]

OSU is in. Don't agree, just wish the playoff committee had specific parameters.

It would blow my ööööing mind if a conference championship and head to head win isn't enough for PSU to jump OSU.

 

[ThisIsAtlanta]

It would blow my ööööing mind if a conference championship and head to head win isn't enough for PSU to jump OSU.

It would blow my mind if one loss OSU who only lost to a top ten conference champion gets jumped by a 2 loss team. They did this to Baylor and TCU once.

 

[Dirty Jacket]

If it is anything but Bama, Clemson, Wash, PSU then we are worse off than the BCS where at least part of the equation was objective. If Ohio State leaps Washington or Penn State that will be ridiculous. PSU has the head to head and conference championship. Washington has done nothing to warrant falling out after beating a team that the committee ranked 8. Ohio State has to be out.

 

[ScionOfSouthland]

Last year conference championships mattered; this year they don't. What?

 

[Keyser Soze]

It would blow my ööööing mind if a conference championship and head to head win isn't enough for PSU to jump OSU.

Might as well get prepared for it.

 

[gt2690b]

It would blow my mind if one loss OSU who only lost to a top ten conference champion gets jumped by a 2 loss team. They did this to Baylor and TCU once.

Except they got jumped by a conference champ right?

By the way.. Winning matters too... Conf champ or not. Plus they rape boys

 

[Dirty Jacket]

It would blow my mind if one loss OSU who only lost to a top ten conference champion gets jumped by a 2 loss team. They did this to Baylor and TCU once.

So what happens to the top 10 conference champion that beat them?

 

[Keyser Soze]

I do hope Penn state gets in

 

[ElCidBUZZingFAN]

Last year conference championships mattered; this year they don't. What?

Ya, this.

 

[jts1207]

It would blow my ööööing mind if a conference championship and head to head win isn't enough for PSU to jump OSU.

Pretend for a moment we are PSU and OSU is Clemson. Now pretend we beat Clemson head to head and just won ACC championship. How pissed would you be if Clemson made it and we were shat on. MSNBC election night pissed.

 

[Valdosta_Jacket]

PSU deserves it even with 2 losses.

 

[ThisIsAtlanta]

So what happens to the top 10 conference champion that beat them?

Quality losses are worth more than head to head.

 

[Dirty Jacket]

Last year conference championships mattered; this year they don't. What?

Matters when it helps keep small market teams out, doesn't matter when it helps get big market teams in. Etc.

 

[gtzulu]

Funny to me that OSU and Michigan thought their game was a play-in game for the playoffs, and now it looks like it was totally irrelevant. Ha ha

 

[Dirty Jacket]

Quality losses are worth more than head to head.

Uhm. No.

 

[fatmike91]

Alabama probably played the weakest schedule of any playoff team. But they are a concensous pick.

Clemson is in. Probably Washington too.

So now pick the team from the Big Integer:

Do we pick the Conference champion or the team the conference champ beat head-to-head instead? C'mon this isn't even difficult.

/