I like ATL. Makes a ton of sense to me at every position but QB and kicker. And sometimes you want to keep those secret.
I understand why coach leaves players returning off the ATL but I would prefer to know and don't think it actually helps the other team when it is less than 48 hours before the game. Also, since we don't name starters, there is no way to know if the player is going to get 5 or 50 snaps so not sure what values it gives the other team.
The reason I would like to know is so that I know who to look for on the field. The way TV coverage works now, it is near impossible to know who is on the field. You hardly ever see "starting" list and the announcers regularly misstates who is in the game.
So I want to know if Ryans is not playing because he is hurt or because he is BTL or other reason. That could be true at many positions.
Basically and hypothetically, I think it adds a little excitement to know that Mason (or Tre) is returning for this week's game and anticipating that versus the anti-climax of seeing him on the field at some point in time.