As one who is comfortable sitting on the sidelines during most of the recruiting threads, I have to be honest and point out my discomfort with the tone of some of the posts - if not posters - in this thread and in similar threads over the years.
There appear to be three types of posters in these recruiting threads: relentlessly positive, relentlessly negative and generally objective.
Over the last five/six years, there has been a contingent of relentlessly positive posters. I don't take names but I'm trying to reconcile those posts over CPJ's last few years with what we now all accept as the empty cupboard CGC inherited. Then I'm trying to reconcile the obvious conclusion of that analysis with the relentlessly positive posters regarding this and last year's classes.
I don't doubt that we are doing better over the last two classes than in the previous three but I think the relentlessly positive posters need to chill on their responses to the skeptical or hesitant posters. We've all heard the positivity before. It might be accurate now and BS before but given that, a certain amount of "I'll believe it when I see it" is not the same thing as relentlessly negative.
Stop poisoning the well and address the questions that are being asked.