ACC Transfer Portal Winners & Losers

The numbers seemed odd so I checked back:

2014: 6, Whitley, Klock, Brown, Preddy, Stickler, Marshall

2015: 2, Morgan & Morgan for the people

2016: 3, Cooper, Lee, Braun. Maybe you don’t count Lee here?

2017: 5, Quinney, Tufele, Minihan, Clark, Hanson

2018: 3, May, McKeehan, Jump

We were averaging 3.8/yr which is 15 OL over 4 years.

Not sure why any of this even matters. They all should be gone by now, they were too little and weak and only knew how to belly flop. Definitely not Key material.
 
Liberty said:
The numbers seemed odd so I checked back:

2014: 6, Whitley, Klock, Brown, Preddy, Stickler, Marshall

2015: 2, Morgan & Morgan for the people

2016: 3, Cooper, Lee, Braun. Maybe you don’t count Lee here?

2017: 5, Quinney, Tufele, Minihan, Clark, Hanson

2018: 3, May, McKeehan, Jump

We were averaging 3.8/yr which is 15 OL over 4 years.

Not sure why any of this even matters. They all should be gone by now, they were too little and weak and only knew how to belly flop. Definitely not Key material.
Click to expand...
You're counting Tight Ends as OL. And Preddy is listed as SDE. That's just the 2014 class.

247sports.com

Georgia Tech 2014 Football Commits

Georgia Tech
247sports.com 247sports.com
 
I thought the TE deal was new for us, but you learn something new every day. I could have sworn Preddy was recruited as a tackle, but my memory’s not what it used to be. If Lee is classified as a DL, that takes the average down to 3.4 or 13 in 4 yrs
 
Liberty said:
I thought the TE deal was new for us, but you learn something new every day. I could have sworn Preddy was recruited as a tackle, but my memory’s not what it used to be. If Lee is classified as a DL, that takes the average down to 3.4 or 13 in 4 yrs
Click to expand...
2018: Mckeehan was also an SDE
2017: Tufele was a DT
My numbers when removing DL and TE's comes to 2.5 OL per year.

Honestly, this points to an even bigger issue. We recruited a bunch of DL and converted them to OL.
 
Liberty said:
Not sure why any of this even matters. They all should be gone by now, they were too little and weak and only knew how to belly flop. Definitely not Key material.
Click to expand...
Forgot to answer this. It only matters for the topic of the conversation that was being had: CPJ's lack of OL recruiting. It doesn't matter for anything for this team now.
 
aeromech said:
Great, now look how much it has changed since CPJ left:

2019 - Alabama (5), Tech (0)
2020 - Alabama (3), Tech (6)
2021 - Alabama (5), Tech (2)
2022 - Alabama (3), Tech (3)
4 year total Alabama (16), Tech (11)
Click to expand...
You left off transfer OL :

2019 - Alabama (1), Tech (1)
2020 - Alabama (0), Tech (2)
2021 - Alabama (0), Tech (2)
2022 - Alabama (0), Tech (2) so far

So that makes it Bama (17), Tech (18)
 
GoGATech said:
You left off transfer OL :

2019 - Alabama (1), Tech (1)
2020 - Alabama (0), Tech (2)
2021 - Alabama (0), Tech (2)
2022 - Alabama (0), Tech (2) so far

So that makes it Bama (17), Tech (18)
Click to expand...
Check how many transfers actually made an impact for our team
 
CarsonNewmanJacket said:
I read it, you might want to stop loving up to Collins after he’s gone this year
Click to expand...
So you have no argument then? Didn’t think so. You may want to go back to my original posts in this thread. They had nothing to do with CGC. I only referenced CPJ and his lack of OL recruiting. Aeromech is the one that brought CGC into it.

Again, you may want to stop opening your mouth.
 
GTWannaBee said:
Forgot to answer this. It only matters for the topic of the conversation that was being had: CPJ's lack of OL recruiting. It doesn't matter for anything for this team now.
Click to expand...
I just hope that Long has brought some special sauce with him. We need it. QBs running for their lives does not make a winning team.
 
Liberty said:
I just hope that Long has brought some special sauce with him. We need it. QBs running for their lives does not make a winning team.
Click to expand...
Agree. All the recruiting in the world won’t mean anything if we can’t coach them up.
 
GoGATech said:
Well all but one started, so I would say nearly all? I mean that wasn't our best unit but apparently it could've been worse without them.

And keep moving the goalposts while you're at it.
Click to expand...
I’m not, anybody can get transfers, not everybody plays.
17284156-41F0-4966-B6BE-E8BFCF9799F8.png
 
GTWannaBee said:
So you have no argument then? Didn’t think so. You may want to go back to my original posts in this thread. They had nothing to do with CGC. I only referenced CPJ and his lack of OL recruiting. Aeromech is the one that brought CGC into it.

Again, you may want to stop opening your mouth.
Click to expand...
You love C[sic]GC is my argument. And my argument is that Collins can recruit better than PJ, but he really sucks at developing the talent. And his guys end up being not better than PJs at the same time period.
 
CarsonNewmanJacket said:
You love C[sic]GC is my argument. And my argument is that Collins can recruit better than PJ, but he really sucks at developing the talent. And his guys end up being not better than PJs at the same time period.
Click to expand...
Wow, you really are an idiot.

Argument 1: I don’t love CGC (adding the “sic” is just stupid, but that’s par for the course for you). Unlike you, I’m capable of arguing the facts separately from defending CGC.

Argument 2: This is the part where you really show yourself to be an idiot. You’re basically trying to argue against me while arguing my point. I’ll spell it out for you: CGC is a better recruiter than CPJ - or you could even just say that CPJ sucked at recruiting. Both are valid points. That was my original point that you tried to argue against, but now you’re arguing for that point. Make up your mind and leave the goalposts where they are.

Argument 3: I never even brought up CGC’s development of recruits. That has absolutely nothing to do with the current argument.
 
CarsonNewmanJacket said:
I’m not, anybody can get transfers, not everybody plays.
17284156-41F0-4966-B6BE-E8BFCF9799F8.png
Click to expand...
You're making my point for me. All of our transfer OL started except one - KJ Kirby. He was expected to be quality backup at both tackle spots until he got injured. Injury didn't allow him to cross-train much so he was mainly a LT, and didn't see much playing time because Devin Cochran played nearly every snap. And you are 100% moving the goal posts... apparently you don't know what that means. The whole point of what I'm arguing by adding our transfer OL into the mix is that we are signing more OL with this staff than the past staff. You, along with @aeromech were arguing that we weren't. Since I proved that false, you've "moved the goalposts" to another subject of transfers not panning out.
 
GTWannaBee said:
Wow, you really are an idiot.

Argument 1: I don’t love CGC (adding the “sic” is just stupid, but that’s par for the course for you). Unlike you, I’m capable of arguing the facts separately from defending CGC.

Argument 2: This is the part where you really show yourself to be an idiot. You’re basically trying to argue against me while arguing my point. I’ll spell it out for you: CGC is a better recruiter than CPJ - or you could even just say that CPJ sucked at recruiting. Both are valid points. That was my original point that you tried to argue against, but now you’re arguing for that point. Make up your mind and leave the goalposts where they are.

Argument 3: I never even brought up CGC’s development of recruits. That has absolutely nothing to do with the current argument.
Click to expand...
Argument 1: you clearly do because you defend him tooth and nail even though he’s objectively the worst coach in Tech history. Also if you took any English classes, you would know that sic comes after a typo. I’m saying that because he isn’t a coach. He’s a placeholder for one.

Argument 2: I never said that CPJ was a better recruiter, I’m saying that Collins hasn’t done that great in recruiting other than a few players, and he can’t develop them whatsoever. If there were a tier list to coaches recruiting, Johnson would be a D and Collins would be a C.

Argument 3: so you’re leaving out what the actual part to being a coach is. Recruiting is maybe 20% and development is about 50%.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top