Textbook squats...

JJacket said:
Why would someone be doing max squats 3-4 times a week?
Click to expand...

Poor programming. Though it is possible to squat balls out 3x a week as long as you get enough calories/protein and do nothing in between to allow for sufficient recovery.

So poor programming.
 
RamblinWreck09 said:
Poor programming. Though it is possible to squat balls out 3x a week as long as you get enough calories/protein and do nothing in between to allow for sufficient recovery.

So poor programming.
Click to expand...

That, plus the high impact of running on concrete, is going to crush your knees.

I also know plenty of people who say their form is good, but their knees track way to dark over their toes and don't hit depth.

My knees hurt like crap when I used improper form. When I fixed it, the pain went away and I could squat heavier weights.
 
GTMom said:
It's called Crossfit
Click to expand...

Olympic lifts ad nauseam is a sure fire way to injure yourself. Too many bad coaches who teach improper form on technical lifts that should only be performed 3-5 reps.
 
GoJackets89 said:
Olympic lifts ad nauseam is a sure fire way to injure yourself. Too many bad coaches who teach improper form on technical lifts that should only be performed 3-5 reps.
Click to expand...
My trainer teaches perfect form. Not squats in every WOD but usually 2 out of 3 combined with other high impact such as lunges, box jumps burpees, etc.
 
GTMom said:
My trainer teaches perfect form. Not squats in every WOD but usually 2 out of 3 combined with other high impact such as lunges, box jumps burpees, etc.
Click to expand...

Does he monitor your form for all these exercises for every single rep?

When you get tired your form breaks down and that's when you'll hurt yourself. If your trainer can look at your form and everyone else's at the same time, then correct it, that's impressive.
 
GoJackets89 said:
Does he monitor your form for all these exercises for every single rep?

When you get tired your form breaks down and that's when you'll hurt yourself. If your trainer can look at your form and everyone else's at the same time, then correct it, that's impressive.
Click to expand...
Yes, SHE does:) We do butt to box squats to ensure proper form.
 
GTMom said:
Yes, SHE does:) We do butt to box squats to ensure proper form.
Click to expand...

How dare I assume someone's gender, shame on me.

I was also speaking to the other exercises as well.

The point is, squats with good form aren't to blame for knee pain. Your knee issues are probably from over use without enough time for recovery.

You started by saying squats alone, then added you ran a lot, then heavy squats 3-4 days a week, then to top it off you stated the dreaded word "crossfit".

I applaud you for being healthy and staying fit, but sounds like an overuse issue and not a squat issue. Don't demonize the squats! That's how the terrorists win.
 
GoJackets89 said:
How dare I assume someone's gender, shame on me.

I was also speaking to the other exercises as well.

The point is, squats with good form aren't to blame for knee pain. Your knee issues are probably from over use without enough time for recovery.

You started by saying squats alone, then added you ran a lot, then heavy squats 3-4 days a week, then to top it off you stated the dreaded word "crossfit".

I applaud you for being healthy and staying fit, but sounds like an overuse issue and not a squat issue. Don't demonize the squats! That's how the terrorists win.
Click to expand...
Ok I will concede it could possibly be more than the squats but that's when the knee pain began was during squats so I naturally assumed....
 
GTMom said:
It's called Crossfit
Click to expand...
Crossfitters aren't doing "max" squats. Most I've seen use plates that look like 45's, but are actually rubber plated and half the weight or so. I don't think you have a true grasp of what a "max", bar bending, squat is.
 
JJacket said:
Crossfitters aren't doing "max" squats. Most I've seen use plates that look like 45's, but are actually rubber plated and half the weight or so. I don't think you have a true grasp of what a "max", bar bending, squat is.
Click to expand...

Thank you. Max reps does not equal max effort. Totally different muscle activation and impact to the nervous system. The most extreme squat routine I've ever seen is by Jamie Lewis, who works primarily in single reps for dozens of sets. I tried it once and I was so exhausted halfway through I had to quit like the little baby I was. It isn't physically possible naturally to work in max effort squats 3-4x per week and expect to get any kind of performance after the first day. The body just doesn't work that way.
 
ScionOfSouthland said:
Thank you. Max reps does not equal max effort. Totally different muscle activation and impact to the nervous system. The most extreme squat routine I've ever seen is by Jamie Lewis, who works primarily in single reps for dozens of sets. I tried it once and I was so exhausted halfway through I had to quit like the little baby I was. It isn't physically possible naturally to work in max effort squats 3-4x per week and expect to get any kind of performance after the first day. The body just doesn't work that way.
Click to expand...

You are weak American capitalist pig...(Said in Russian accent)
 
fishinjacket said:
You are weak American capitalist pig...(Said in Russian accent)
Click to expand...

giphy.gif
 
IMG_4620.JPG
JJacket said:
Crossfitters aren't doing "max" squats. Most I've seen use plates that look like 45's, but are actually rubber plated and half the weight or so. I don't think you have a true grasp of what a "max", bar bending, squat is.
Click to expand...
In Crossfit max weight is the most weight each individual can lift with proper form successfully throughout the number of reps required in the WOD. In this example, there are two 15 min AMRAP's ( as many rounds as possible in 15 minutes)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top